Are the Palestinians silencing attempted rape?

N&P: Discussion of news headlines and politics.

Moderator: frigidmagi

Post Reply
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#1 Are the Palestinians silencing attempted rape?

Post by frigidmagi »

Haaretz
The story of the Palestinian popular protest against Israel in several West Bank villages has recently garnered worldwide praise. However, as with any other massive movement, the popular protest too has its darker sides. The Palestinian Authority, as well as the leaders of the Palestinian popular protests in villages such as Bil'in, Na'alim, Umm Salmuna, have been trying to keep the following story away from both public knowledge and the media's eye: One of the more prominent Umm Salmuna activists – a village south of Bethlehem, long entrenched in a battle against the West Bank separation fence – is suspected of the attempted rape of an American peace activist who had been residing in the village as part of her support of the local protest.

Omar Aladdin, who had been arrested three months ago over suspicions he had attempted to rape the U.S. citizen, was subsequently released after agreeing to apologize to the young woman. However, Haaretz had learned that representatives of both the popular protest movement and the PA have since applied pressure on the American peace activist as to prevent her from making the story public.

The incident allegedly took place last April, as Aladdin, who had served a term in the Israeli jail in the past, arrived one evening at the guest house in which many of the foreign peace activists were staying. The European and American female activists reportedly agreed to let Aladdin stay with them after he had told them he feared the Israel Defense Forces were on his tail, adding that he had been severely beaten at an IDF checkpoint only a week before.

During his stay Aladdin allegedly attempted to rape a Muslim-American woman, nicknamed "Fegin" by fellow activists. The woman escaped, later accusing the popular protest man of the attempt. One villager who had encountered the American following the incident said she had been in a state of shock.

Aladdin then refused to apologize for the incident, when news of it reached the village's popular committee, the popular protests' governing body, allegedly saying that the incident had been marginal and normal. The American activist then asked the committee to notify authorities of the attempted rape, a request which resulted in the man being arrested by security forces in Bethlehem. After agreeing to apologize for the incident, Aladdin was released from custody by the PA police.

The U.S. citizen was then convinced to retract her complaint, as to avoid tainting the image of the popular protest, which had attracted praise from around the world in recent months.

However, the Umm Salmuna case is not the only one. Separation fence activists know of other incidents in which Palestinians molested and sexually assaulted foreign peace activists, a subject which was apparently raised in the discussions of the various popular committees.

Foreign female peace activists regularly participate in protests in the villages of Bil'in, Na'alin, and others, where the activists stay in separate houses. Some villagers do not agree with these housing arrangements, claiming that the villages' youth, who frequently visit the activists, are corrupted by the young women.

One villager said the female activists bring a different "culture with them, western, too open. The young people, especially from the villages, aren’t used to stay near other girls, they do not know their culture, certainly when it’s a young woman staying with other women in a strange house. They misinterpret it."

Mahmoud Zwahara, the popular committee's coordinator for the Umm Salmuna and Ma'sara region, said in response that "the struggle against the separation fence is a joint fight, which does not target Israeli identity or Jews. We hope that our activity will show the Israeli soldiers that they must cease their actions against us as well as human rights violations."
As I post this, I pray that this is either a hoax or an isolated incident. Meanwhile on sources I am unsure of, there are stories of this being widespread behavior towards foreign born female activists and of the activist organizations choosing to cover this up. In fact there are stories of female activist being raped repeatedly and forced into marriages, something I pray fervently is untrue. Not for any political reasons but for the sake of the ladies in question.

I would really like to hear from our Israeli posters. I am told that Haaretz is a trustworthy source and in fact I have posted stories from there here before... But this leaves me rattled.

Additionally, where is our government? Let me be crystal clear. It is my belief that an American Citizen has a right to his or her government's protection no matter where on the planet he or she may happen to be... Well there are limits. One should not expect the US to be able to do much if you're in Tehran for example, but damn it our nation should still try! It is because of this belief that I am often in the position of viewing the State Department's actions with profound disgust and dismay. Theodore Roosevelt once deployed a battleship task group for the sake of a single kidnapped man. Today our state department won't even deploy a single lawyer. I'm not saying people like Amanda Knox should be extracted by gunpoint but I imagine her stay with Italian police would have been less stressful if someone from the American embassy had been there ensuring she wasn't mistreated. I'm not asking for US armies to swoop down to save every teen who gets in trouble in foreign lands but I do think we should make it clear that we are profoundly interested in the rights and well being of our citizens overseas.
Last edited by frigidmagi on Sat Sep 25, 2010 1:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
rhoenix
The Artist formerly known as Rhoenix
Posts: 7998
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 4:01 pm
17
Location: "Here," for varying values of "here."
Contact:

#2

Post by rhoenix »

It does raise the question of why our government isn't coming fiercely to the defense of Americans abroad.

Considering that the US is touted as "the world's only remaining superpower," it doesn't make sense to mark this up as simple spinelessless or even apathy about its own citizenry.

However... there isn't much other evidence to form a position from, unless the message is that the US government is more concerned with the Palestinian/Israeli peace talks moving forward than with our citizens abroad.
Last edited by rhoenix on Sat Sep 25, 2010 2:19 am, edited 1 time in total.
"Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self-esteem, make sure that you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes."

- William Gibson


Josh wrote:What? There's nothing weird about having a pet housefly. He smuggles cigarettes for me.
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#3

Post by frigidmagi »

This doesn't even have to impact Palestinian/Israeli peace talks. Nor is it an issue that occurs solely in that area. American citizens can be kidnapped, arrested and abused and our government refuses to even mention it. Look what happened to Amanda Knox in Italy. Or to several American women who married Suadi men.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
rhoenix
The Artist formerly known as Rhoenix
Posts: 7998
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 4:01 pm
17
Location: "Here," for varying values of "here."
Contact:

#4

Post by rhoenix »

frigidmagi wrote:This doesn't even have to impact Palestinian/Israeli peace talks. Nor is it an issue that occurs solely in that area. American citizens can be kidnapped, arrested and abused and our government refuses to even mention it. Look what happened to Amanda Knox in Italy. Or to several American women who married Suadi men.
That really is disgusting - I remember you mentioning this now.

Given what I see so far, I can't really look beyond "apathy" as a reason for our government to not come to the immediate and loud defense of its citizens abroad, despite really not liking that conclusion.
"Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self-esteem, make sure that you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes."

- William Gibson


Josh wrote:What? There's nothing weird about having a pet housefly. He smuggles cigarettes for me.
User avatar
Steve
Master
Posts: 2072
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2006 6:14 pm
18
Contact:

#5

Post by Steve »

It's institutional rot and corruption in the State Department, as the rank and file are more concerned with "smoothing feathers" and "making deals" with the countries they're assigned to than actually fulfilling the purpose of representing American interests. And I fear we'd need someone of vision, wise temperament, decisiveness, and a bit of ruthlessness to enact any meaningful institutional reform. Changing SecStates and upper level executives isn't enough, you need to deal with an entire organization of civil servants who have wide-spread protections against termination (IIRC above a certain rank, but below the senior official ones where the POTUS and Senate have direct authority, terminations require full hearings of a committee on the subject where the employee can defend himself and attempt to avoid the termination).

I've always had the fantasy of being POTUS (like that will ever happen) and using my authority as C-in-C to have the Marine garrisons of embassies protect American women trying to keep their children from abusive foreign fathers (like so many examples in Saudi Arabia) regardless of what the officials in the Embassy say. Instructions would be for the Ambassador or whichever official was trying to turn them back over to local authorities to contact me, and until then the Marines would care for them and provide protection from seizure by local authorities or the Embassy officials.

Yeah, it'd probably cause one hell of a crisis - political, diplomatic, and governmental - but it'd be well worth it. :cool:
Chatniks on the (nonexistant) risks of the Large Hadron Collector:
"The chance of Shep talking his way into the control room for an ICBM is probably higher than that." - Seth
"Come on, who wouldn't trade a few dozen square miles of French countryside for Warp 3.5?" - Marina
User avatar
Cynical Cat
Arch-Magician
Posts: 11930
Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2005 8:53 pm
19
Location: Ice Sarcophagus outside a ruined Jedi Temple
Contact:

#6

Post by Cynical Cat »

Its an ingrained attitude that will be hard to change and it doesn't have to be that way. My country isn't awesome on this particular subject either, but the Brits are pretty damn good. They have a special unit that deals with forced marriages and kidnappings and there are SAS guys assigned to that unit if sweet reason fails to bring about the desired result.
It's not that I'm unforgiving, it's that most of the people who wrong me are unrepentant assholes.
Post Reply