LibriumArcana.Games

Posted: **Fri Nov 14, 2014 12:09 pm**

A double whammy of falling oil prices and sanctions imposed over Ukraine has led to rampant inflation, a plunging currency, a stagnant economy and a loss of confidence among foreign investors.

The Russian central bank said Monday it expected no growth in 2015, and little improvement the following year, confirming what many economists and external officials have been saying for months.
Here are five reasons the country could face even tougher times:

1. Banks squeezed
Russian banks have amassed about $192 billion in foreign debts, but have very few assets in dollars to set against them.
The plunging ruble, combined with the lack of dollar income, is making it harder for the banks to repay that debt. If the ruble remains at its current level, the additional cost to Russia's banks could be as much as $22 billion, Capital Economics estimates. That's equivalent to more than 1% of the Russian economy.

2. Budget hole
Government documents show that Russia's 2015-2017 budget is based on oil trading at $100 a barrel. The central bank forecast of zero growth next year is based on a price of $95. Both assumptions are way above the current price of $84 a barrel.

Finance minister Anton Siluanov has called that an "alternative economic reality". He has warned that the government will need to cut spending by 10% to make up for the difference.

Oil and gas accounts for more than half of Russian government revenues.

3. Sanctions
Tensions in the region are rising again. Ukraine has accused Russia of sending yet another armored column into its territory, while the town of Donetsk has just seen the worst outbreak of violence in over a month. Russia has also recognized elections held by separatists in eastern Ukraine last week.

All this is fueling speculation that the West might step up its sanctions, which are already sinking the Russian economy. The central bank said Monday it expects the measures to last until 2017.

The bank now expects foreign capital outflows to hit $128 billion this year, up $38 billion on its previous estimate. Next year will see another $100 billion leave the country, it estimates.

4. Inflation
The tit-for-tat sanctions Russia imposed on Europe, the U.S., and other western countries have backfired. The near complete ban on Western food imports is pushing Russian inflation up. The central bank now expects inflation to exceed 8% in 2014 -- well above its 5% target.

Looking ahead, the bank's 4% target for 2016 is now unrealistic. The bank said it hoped to reach it in 2017 -- barring any more economic disasters.

5. Putin in denial
Despite the warnings from his own ministers and central bankers, Russian President Vladimir Putin seems to be in denial about the state of the economy.

"These events in the currency market which we see now in Russia are not at all connected to the fundamental economic reasons and factors," he said

Well... I guess Sanctions can work. Although a good amount of the credit has to go to the Saudi's who have been working overtime to keep the price of oil down partly to smack Russia for supporting Assad and to fuck with Iran, who they want to keep poor and nukeless.

Posted: **Fri Nov 14, 2014 4:26 pm**

I don't think there's much disagreement on whether sanctions work to depress or even tank a country's economy. The argument is usually that the sanctions don't serve to change whatever course of action instigated them in the first place. Instead they only succeed at making people suffer while their leadership is no more than mildly inconvenienced. To the credit of the United States and Europe, they are aware of this and the very first sanctions largely attempted to target the assets and finances of Russia's oligarchs. They only expanded into more traditional economic sanctions when the first effort failed to do anything.

For my part, I agree that sanctions do little to change a country's current course of action. To bow before that kind of pressure tends to look weak rather than wise, and that is not conductive toward the leadership keeping their hold on power, which is generally their first priority. That is not to say, however, that sanctions are ineffective. While they won't affect present actions, but I do believe that they affect future actions. When the target country's leadership next weighs whether or not to do something, knowing just how much sanctions can hurt may very well make them hesitant to once again do something that would invoke them.

Unfortunately this presents a bit of a sticky problem with respect to the people who are caught in the middle. The sanctioned party can't back down when economically pressured because that only invites further uses of that kind of pressure in the future. However, the sanctioned party can't lift the sanctions either because that will just tell everyone that they can be waited out. The result is usually a long-standing impasse. Generally only resolved when both sides can come to some sort of agreement that makes them all look like winners. I couldn't tell you what that sort of agreement would look like in this case, but I can tell you the Russians are expecting they'll be able to wait the West out. We'll see whether or not they're right.

LibriumArcana.Games

Russia's Central Bank Forecast's 0 growth in 2015.

#1 Russia's Central Bank Forecast's 0 growth in 2015.

#2 Re: Russia's Central Bank Forecast's 0 growth in 2015.