US question, should Civics be required?
Moderator: frigidmagi
- frigidmagi
- Dragon Death-Marine General
- Posts: 14757
- Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
- 19
- Location: Alone and unafraid
#1 US question, should Civics be required?
A recent qoute from a senator declared that prisoners in Abu Garib had ad their Constitutional Rights violated. Given the context, it seemed to me that he meant the US Constitution.
Abu Garib was indeed a illegal event. But the Constitution of the US was not the law broken in this event. Why?
Because the Constitution only applys to US citizens and legal aliens dwelling within the US. It does not apply to foregin prisoners on foregin soil who just happen to be held by US troops. The laws violated by the event were the Geneva Convention, Iraqi Domenstice Law and the UCMJ of the United States Military. Events like these and others led me to ask
Should we make Civic classes whose prime goal will be teach students about the Constitution and other US laws and government functions, required to graduate? As in if you fail this class you get to do the year over.
Abu Garib was indeed a illegal event. But the Constitution of the US was not the law broken in this event. Why?
Because the Constitution only applys to US citizens and legal aliens dwelling within the US. It does not apply to foregin prisoners on foregin soil who just happen to be held by US troops. The laws violated by the event were the Geneva Convention, Iraqi Domenstice Law and the UCMJ of the United States Military. Events like these and others led me to ask
Should we make Civic classes whose prime goal will be teach students about the Constitution and other US laws and government functions, required to graduate? As in if you fail this class you get to do the year over.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
- Josh
- Resident of the Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
- Posts: 8114
- Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2005 4:51 pm
- 19
- Location: Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
#2
Well, yes.
While we're at it we can fail students who can't read, can't write comprehensibly, and can't do basic mathematics.
It would be a good start.
While we're at it we can fail students who can't read, can't write comprehensibly, and can't do basic mathematics.
It would be a good start.
Last edited by Josh on Fri Sep 29, 2006 1:40 pm, edited 2 times in total.
When the Frog God smiles, arm yourself.
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
- Stofsk
- Secret Agent Man
- Posts: 1710
- Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 4:46 pm
- 19
- Location: Melbourne, Australia
- Contact:
#3
But then the stupid kids will complain. Or try to anyway, furrowing their brows in a vain attempt at understanding their situation. I mean, failing students because they have poor grades? Perish the thought! :eek:
- Josh
- Resident of the Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
- Posts: 8114
- Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2005 4:51 pm
- 19
- Location: Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
#4
I know you're being facetious Chris, but we reeeeeally do need to reintroduce the concept of failure into the system. I mean stark, demoralizing, shitty failure. There's way too much insulation from that sort of thing and has been since I was a kid.
In any event, it's a derail from the original topic, though. Now, in the case of Senator Whoever here, was he really that ignorant, or was he just banking on public ignorance? Either way, it's not a good situation.
In any event, it's a derail from the original topic, though. Now, in the case of Senator Whoever here, was he really that ignorant, or was he just banking on public ignorance? Either way, it's not a good situation.
When the Frog God smiles, arm yourself.
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
- Comrade Tortoise
- Exemplar
- Posts: 4832
- Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2005 1:33 am
- 19
- Location: Land of steers and queers indeed
- Contact:
#5
Thankfully, in my state, a Government class is required. But I think it should be a universal one. People need to know what the constitution means and the context in which it was written.
"Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution."
- Theodosius Dobzhansky
There is no word harsh enough for this. No verbal edge sharp and cold enough to set forth the flaying needed. English is to young and the elder languages of the earth beyond me. ~Frigid
The Holocaust was an Amazing Logistical Achievement~Havoc
- Theodosius Dobzhansky
There is no word harsh enough for this. No verbal edge sharp and cold enough to set forth the flaying needed. English is to young and the elder languages of the earth beyond me. ~Frigid
The Holocaust was an Amazing Logistical Achievement~Havoc
- B4UTRUST
- Dance Puppets Dance
- Posts: 4867
- Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 3:31 pm
- 19
- Location: Chesapeake, Va
- Contact:
#6
More people in America can name members of the Simpsons then they can state amendments to the constitution.
Yes, we need a class to teach our youth about their rights, liberties and responsibilities. If nothing else, so that they can learn about these rights before they're stripped away.
Yes, we need a class to teach our youth about their rights, liberties and responsibilities. If nothing else, so that they can learn about these rights before they're stripped away.
Saint Annihilus - Patron Saint of Dealing with Stupid Customers
- Batman
- The Dark Knight
- Posts: 4357
- Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2006 4:47 am
- 18
- Location: The Timmverse, the only place where DC Comics still make a modicum of sense
- Contact:
#7
I still have come to grips with this 'no child left behind' nonsense. If you no longer get failing grades what's the point of grading? I realize I'm no american and it's been a while since I've been in high school but back in my day if you failed, you failed.
The purpose of school is to teach and if the students aren't learning, show them in a manner they'll understand (i.e. failing grades).
I realize that's only part of the problem (you can't blame the students for the failures of the school system) but back in my school days at least, somebody graduating the local equivalent of primary school leave alone high school without being able to read and write german properly and doing basic math would have been unthinkable.
The purpose of school is to teach and if the students aren't learning, show them in a manner they'll understand (i.e. failing grades).
I realize that's only part of the problem (you can't blame the students for the failures of the school system) but back in my school days at least, somebody graduating the local equivalent of primary school leave alone high school without being able to read and write german properly and doing basic math would have been unthinkable.
'I wonder how far the barometer sunk.'-'All der way. Trust me on dis.'
'Go ahead. Bake my quiche'.
'Undead or alive, you're coming with me.'
'Detritus?'-'Yessir?'-'Never go to Klatch'.-'Yessir.'
'Many fine old manuscripts in that place, I believe. Without price, I'm told.'-'Yes, sir. Certainly worthless, sir.'-'Is it possible you misunderstood what I just said, Commander?'
'Can't sing, can't dance, can handle a sword a little'
'Run away, and live to run away another day'-The Rincewind principle
'Hello, inner child. I'm the inner babysitter.'
'Go ahead. Bake my quiche'.
'Undead or alive, you're coming with me.'
'Detritus?'-'Yessir?'-'Never go to Klatch'.-'Yessir.'
'Many fine old manuscripts in that place, I believe. Without price, I'm told.'-'Yes, sir. Certainly worthless, sir.'-'Is it possible you misunderstood what I just said, Commander?'
'Can't sing, can't dance, can handle a sword a little'
'Run away, and live to run away another day'-The Rincewind principle
'Hello, inner child. I'm the inner babysitter.'
- Something Awesome
- Initiate
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2005 7:44 pm
- 18
- Location: Somewhere Awesome
- Contact:
#8
Participation In Government was a graduation requirement at my high school, and I'm not sure if it was a state thing or what. Everyone complains about it. The not so bright students hated it because it was too much work or something, and the decent students know it's a bullshit class. Anything of value in it was taught in US History the year before. It was only a semester long class, but it still takes up a spot on our schedules that could have been put to better use with pretty much anything else.
#9
We require math on the basis that we need it. We require English on the basis that we need it. We require science on the basis that we need it.
Yet there are other basic skills that we, as citizens, need in order to live. We need more than a basic understanding of economics, we need practical education in how to manage our finances. We need to understand how banks and loans and credit cards and debit cards work, how to deal with insurance, what happens when we are involved in fraud and theft.
We also need to understand how our society is designed to work. We need to understand that politics is more than just what we see in high school with our overblown popularity contests. We need the basis for this education in primary schools.
We also need to understand how the rest of the world works. Diplomacy, intelligence, what other governments are like, how they work, and what the rest of the world is like.
We also should have classes about religion. That's right, I said public schools teaching about religion. Mind you, not teaching religion itself, but the tenants of the world's religions and beliefs. Not about teaching which is right, but exposing children to all types of religions so they can understand at least what other people believe.
Yet there are other basic skills that we, as citizens, need in order to live. We need more than a basic understanding of economics, we need practical education in how to manage our finances. We need to understand how banks and loans and credit cards and debit cards work, how to deal with insurance, what happens when we are involved in fraud and theft.
We also need to understand how our society is designed to work. We need to understand that politics is more than just what we see in high school with our overblown popularity contests. We need the basis for this education in primary schools.
We also need to understand how the rest of the world works. Diplomacy, intelligence, what other governments are like, how they work, and what the rest of the world is like.
We also should have classes about religion. That's right, I said public schools teaching about religion. Mind you, not teaching religion itself, but the tenants of the world's religions and beliefs. Not about teaching which is right, but exposing children to all types of religions so they can understand at least what other people believe.
#10
Civics and government is a graduation requirement in Indiana.
The Paladin's Domain, My Blog (Updated 5/18/2009)
"Live free or die: Death is not the worst of evils." -- General John Stark
"A fortress circumvented ceases to be an obstacle.
A fortress destroyed ceases to be a threat.
Do not forget the difference."
"Fairy tales do not tell children the dragons exist. Children already know that dragons exist. Fairy tales tell children the dragons can be killed." -- G. K. Chesterton
"Live free or die: Death is not the worst of evils." -- General John Stark
"A fortress circumvented ceases to be an obstacle.
A fortress destroyed ceases to be a threat.
Do not forget the difference."
"Fairy tales do not tell children the dragons exist. Children already know that dragons exist. Fairy tales tell children the dragons can be killed." -- G. K. Chesterton
#11
There is often a great deal of confusion among Americans when it comes to understanding the boundaries that exist around the rights they take for granted. The classic example is the First Amendment; most Americans (especially on the internet) seem to love to invoke it as though it says you can say whatever you want and nobody else (including individual other citizens) has a right to prevent you, and that this is true no matter where they go or where they might be.Petrosjko wrote:In any event, it's a derail from the original topic, though. Now, in the case of Senator Whoever here, was he really that ignorant, or was he just banking on public ignorance? Either way, it's not a good situation.
I'm all for there being discussion of the rights that military prisoners in an age of insurgency and terrorism should and shouldn't have-- I think it's a very important topic-- but there's no way in hell there can be anything like rational progress on the topic if the people doing the talking don't even understand what is and isn't relevant.
Still, to the main question, I say: It doesn't matter what we teach or don't teach kids in American schools. On average, they're going to succeed through guile, nepotism, or money, or fail because they don't have access to those things. All other factors (like "what they know") are second-order.
(Admittedly, the occasional rare prodigy will succeed because he or she is ambitious, works hard, and/or is very talented, but again, their success is not going to come because they know Constitutional Law out of high school.)
--The Elder Dan
Dan Curtis Johnson | com . mac . crisper | Moreover, I advise that Carthage be destroyed.
- frigidmagi
- Dragon Death-Marine General
- Posts: 14757
- Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
- 19
- Location: Alone and unafraid
#12
I think you would be shocked how many of us graduated High School because we actually knew the material.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
- Josh
- Resident of the Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
- Posts: 8114
- Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2005 4:51 pm
- 19
- Location: Kingdom of Eternal Cockjobbery
#13
Well, I'm a firm believe we need a great deal of deep reform in our school system. Right now, it's utterly failing.
There were several good teachers who broadened my horizons when I was in school, but I can say that a significant portion of my education beyond absorbing the basics came from my own studies.
Edit- Oh, and HEY DAN! How's the wee sprout?
There were several good teachers who broadened my horizons when I was in school, but I can say that a significant portion of my education beyond absorbing the basics came from my own studies.
Edit- Oh, and HEY DAN! How's the wee sprout?
Last edited by Josh on Sat Sep 30, 2006 4:39 am, edited 1 time in total.
When the Frog God smiles, arm yourself.
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
"'Flammable' and 'inflammable' have the same meaning! This language is insane!"
GIVE ME COFFEE AND I WILL ALLOW YOU TO LIVE!- Frigid
"Ork 'as no automatic code o' survival. 'is partic'lar distinction from all udda livin' gits is tha necessity ta act inna face o' alternatives by means o' dakka."
I created the sound of madness, wrote the book on pain
- Mayabird
- Leader of the Marching Band
- Posts: 1635
- Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 7:53 pm
- 19
- Location: IA > GA
- Contact:
#14
Some kind of civics/government class is required in Georgia for graduation. I took it. I don't know about other schools, but since it was required it was basically a bullshit class like Health. That was the teacher who picked on girls in class because he had issues with his height (he was shorter than I am) and had "civics lessons" that consisted of us watching Bill O'Reilly. He positively idolized that dumbass, since it was proof that a useless windbag social studies teacher could become rich and famous just by ranting mindlessly. And I'll stop here before I go on for the next several hours.
- Mared
- Pleasure Kitten
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2006 9:45 pm
- 18
- Location: My castle on the shores of Ireland
- Contact:
#15
Civics is a required course in Louisiana. However, like most previous posts it is only one semester long and seen as an easy A and wasted time.
I think it should be required as a comprehensive class that should be taken at least twice (maybe once in upper elmentary and again in high school). I am after all and Secondary Social Studies Education Major.
On a further note: If anyone would like to get into a debate on how utterly shitty the US Education system is, see me. Because, trust me, you have no idea how bad it really is until you try to become part of that system. I know more shit about NCLB than I care to think about and none of it makes me particularly happy. If you're interested you know how to find me....
I think it should be required as a comprehensive class that should be taken at least twice (maybe once in upper elmentary and again in high school). I am after all and Secondary Social Studies Education Major.
On a further note: If anyone would like to get into a debate on how utterly shitty the US Education system is, see me. Because, trust me, you have no idea how bad it really is until you try to become part of that system. I know more shit about NCLB than I care to think about and none of it makes me particularly happy. If you're interested you know how to find me....
There is a really good chance that I am seriously fucked up. But don't worry....I like me that way.