Hezbollah rejects war criticism

[frigidmagi]

BBC

The Lebanese government and Hezbollah have condemned a watchdog report which criticises Hezbollah's conduct in the conflict against Israel last year.

The report by Human Rights Watch accuses Hezbollah of "indiscriminately and at times deliberately" targeting Israeli civilians.

The group called off the report's launch in Beirut on Thursday on hearing that Hezbollah planned to disrupt it.

Human Rights Watch accused Hezbollah of trying to silence criticism.

The report says Hezbollah forces fired long-range rockets that "were highly inaccurate and could not distinguish between civilians and military objectives", resulting in at least 39 Israeli civilian deaths.

The New York-based group says Hezbollah's justifications for attacking Israeli towns - as a response to indiscriminate Israeli fire into southern Lebanon - have no legal basis under the laws of war.


We did not target civilians but Israel did
Hezbollah spokesman

A spokesman for Hezbollah, Hussein Rahal, said Human Rights Watch should start by criticising Israel.

"We were the victims during this war and people have a right to defend themselves," he told AFP.

"We did not target civilians but Israel on the other hand did target the civilian population in Lebanon."

Criticism also came from the Lebanese prime minister's office.

"Israel during the attacks of July 2006 violated all international conventions," it said in a statement.

Human Rights Watch is due to release a big report, into civilian deaths in Lebanon during the conflict, in September.

'Protecting civilians'

The group said it cancelled its Beirut news conference on Thursday when it heard that Hezbollah was planning to disrupt it, and the hotel therefore refused to host the event.

In a statement, HRW said its focus was on protecting civilians, not on taking sides in a conflict.

"Hezbollah is trying to silence criticism of its conduct during the 2006 war," said Sarah Leah Whitson, director of the group's Middle East division.

"The fairness and accuracy of our reporting will speak for themselves, whether we hold a press conference or not."

My respect for the Human Rights Watch just went up a notch.

[frigidmagi]

As for Hezbollah's claim of not targeting civilans... Bullshit.

BBC

An Israeli Arab man critically wounded in a rocket attack during the 2006 Lebanon war has died from his wounds.

Muhammad Salum was severely burned, blinded and lost a leg when a Hezbollah rocket struck his home in the northern Israeli city of Haifa last August.

The 40-year-old had been in intensive care in a Haifa hospital since then, and there had been times when the family hoped he might recover.

He was the 40th civilian fatality of the war on the Israeli side.

Most of the 159 Israelis killed were soldiers. More than 1,000 Lebanese, most of them civilians, also died in the 34-day war.

"There were weeks when we felt that his condition may be improving. We even made sure to modify the house in order to cater to his needs, removing staircases and enabling wheelchair access," said his sister, Munira Salum.

However, she said that his condition had worsened during the last week.

The Haaretz newspaper has reported that the family has yet to receive compensation from the Israeli authorities for the damage to their house.

I should note even with unguided missiles one can avoid hitting a city, say be aiming at a military base... Or (and this is a crazy idea I'm just tossing out for fun) not kidnapping Israel citizens and starting a war.