Radical Iraq Cleric in Retreat?

N&P: Discussion of news headlines and politics.

Moderator: frigidmagi

Post Reply
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#1 Radical Iraq Cleric in Retreat?

Post by frigidmagi »

WSJ
Anti-American cleric Muqtada al-Sadr -- long a thorn in the side of the U.S. military and Iraqi government -- intends to disarm his once-dominant Mahdi Army militia and remake it as a social-services organization.

The transformation would represent a significant turnabout for a group that, as recently as earlier this year, was seen as one of the most destabilizing anti-American forces in Iraq. For much of the past several years, the Mahdi Army, headed by Mr. Sadr, a Shiite cleric, controlled sizable chunks of Baghdad and other cities. Its brand of pro-Shiite activism had the side effect of pitting Iraqis against each other, helping to stir worries of civil war.

Recently, however, the group has been hit by a largely successful Iraqi military crackdown against militia members operating as criminal gangs. At the same time, Mr. Sadr's popular support is dwindling: Residents who once viewed the Mahdi Army as champions of the poor became alienated by what they saw as its thuggish behavior.

A new brochure, obtained by The Wall Street Journal and confirmed by Mr. Sadr's chief spokesman, Sheik Salah al-Obeidi, states that the Mahdi Army will now be guided by Shiite spirituality instead of anti-American militancy. The group will focus on education, religion and social justice, according to the brochure, which is aimed at Mr. Sadr's followers. The brochure also states that it "is not allowed to use arms at all."

Posters have been put up in some areas of Baghdad saying a new direction for the Mahdi Army will be announced at this Friday's prayers.

The Mahdi Army has long stated that its principal goal is withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq. Since talks of setting a goal for a timetable for withdrawal have emerged -- as part of the long-term security deal between the U.S. and Iraq currently nearing completion -- the movement now intends to try to help Iraqi society via peaceful means, according to Mr. Obeidi.

See continuing coverage of developments in Iraq, including an interactive map of day-to-day events in Iraq and a tally of military deaths.

Disarmament is far from certain. The group is ridden with internal strife, and Mr. Sadr now is believed to spend significant time outside the country, in Iran.

U.S. military spokesman Col. Jerry O'Hara said the military welcomed the news, but said "the proof is always in the actions and not just the words, so we'll take a wait-and-see approach."

The Mahdi Army's makeover is at least partly a reaction to the loss of popular support. Previously, many Iraqis blamed the U.S. and the Iraqi government for fighting that erupted with the militia, but in the most recent battles that began in March, many residents turned against the militia because they were fed up with its criminal and violent activities, including kidnapping and smuggling.

This reorganization reflects a major effort by Mr. Sadr to regain grass-roots support and weed out some more extremist elements. Mr. Sadr has expressed frustration at individuals who have continued fighting U.S. and Iraqi security forces despite a cease-fire hammered out in May, following the Iraqi crackdown that began in Basra in late March.

He faces big challenges. Hard-liners within the Mahdi Army will likely reject Mr. Sadr's new strategy, just as they have ignored his orders to freeze violent activities as part of a cease-fire. These members have also been threatening -- and assassinating -- rivals who support the cease-fire.
[A Different Kind of Force]

This leaves in question whether more moderate members will take the risky step of working to implement Mr. Sadr's strategy, or instead remain underground as many of them have. "We know it will take time to get rid of these bad elements, and even some good people joined them because they fell into a trap," said Sheik Abu Ali, a moderate Mahdi Army leader and cleric whose brother was kidnapped by fellow Mahdi Army members because of his views. Since then, he stopped his religious work but is hoping the new strategy will make him feel safe enough to resume teaching.

If successful, Mr. Sadr's shift could widen his role on Iraq's political stage. Mr. Sadr's followers already have seats in Parliament. The group also plans to endorse independent candidates it favors in the next provincial elections, although the movement won't field candidates itself.

Logical Step

Kenneth Pollack, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, said turning the Mahdi Army into a civic and political organization was a logical step given the weakening of the militia after the crackdown in Basra, Sadr City and Amarah. Indeed, in the long term, it could help legitimize the movement. "If the government fails to deliver on basic services and other needs of the Iraqis, Sadr followers could use their new organization to tell people they should look to them as voice of change," Mr. Pollack said.

Until recently, the Mahdi Army had enjoyed widespread popular support in areas of Baghdad and in the southern Shiite area of Iraq because it was known to help the poor by giving them money, food and other aid. But its popularity began to wane in the past few months as some members turned increasingly to criminal activity such as taking control of gas stations and extorting money from merchants in exchange for protection.

According to the new brochure, the Mahdi Army will now adhere to the guiding principle of "al-Mumahidoon," which translates roughly as "those who are paving the way" in Arabic. It's a reference to people who are awaiting the return of Imam Muhammad al-Mahdi, a revered religious figure in Shia Islam, who Shiites believe will come back to rid the world of evil and injustice.

Mr. Sadr isn't giving up armed resistance entirely. Mr. Obeidi said Mr. Sadr will continue to direct small, special armed cells for limited military operations against U.S. forces. He said specific details about these cells, and how they can be distinguished from rogue Mahdi Army members, will be publicized at a future date.

The actions of the Mahdi Army have enormous impact on Iraq's stability. For instance, the Basra military crackdown on rogue members in late March sparked fighting across southern Iraq and in Baghdad.

Senior American and British commanders say they have increasingly come to conclude that Mr. Sadr's once-feared militia is in disarray. American officers say Mr. Sadr now spends most of his time in neighboring Iran, where he has talked of pursuing a more advanced course of religious studies.

Earlier this summer, Mr. Sadr said he was creating a new group dedicated solely to attacking American forces. But in a recent interview, Lt. Gen. Lloyd Austin, the day-to-day commander of all American troops here, said he had "not seen any evidence that the group exists."

The southern city of Basra had long been one of Mr. Sadr's primary strongholds, but it is now under the control of the Iraqi army. Mortar attacks have fallen by close to 90%, and the number of bodies that turn up in the city's morgue each day has declined from 30 earlier this year to one or two today.

Tahseen al-Shaikhli, spokesman for the Baghdad security plan, said the Iraqi government is pleased with Mr. Sadr's stated plan for the militia. "We welcome any news about Iraqis laying down their arms and working to rebuild this country," Mr. Shaikhli said.

Regrouping

While the Mahdi Army has been weakened since the Iraqi military operations earlier this year, the extremist elements are regrouping and being trained, with an estimated 5,000 members in Iran. Some U.S. military officials worry there is a chance that the extremists could return.

Abu Karar al-Sadri, a Mahdi Army leader in Baghdad's Rusafa neighborhood who has been against the cease-fire, says he and his men will continue operations despite this new direction for the Mahdi Army. He acknowledged that his fighters had been negatively affected by the crackdown but said they are rebuilding. "We will continue to fight until the occupation is driven out of Iraq," he said.

Mr. Sadr began moving away from military operations when he ordered a cease-fire last August after Mahdi Army members clashed with government forces in the southern city of Karbala during a Shiite religious holiday. The fighting represented growing rivalry between Sadr followers and supporters of the main Shiite parties in government, the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq and the Islamic Dawa Party. In February, Mr. Sadr extended the cease-fire for an additional six months.

Since then, several moderate Sadr followers who favored the cease-fire have been killed. In April, Riyadh al-Nouri, director of Mr. Sadr's office in Najaf, was gunned down following Friday prayers after a rumor circulated that he was supporting the Americans.

Mr. Abu Ali, the cleric -- who had been a good friend of Mr. Nouri's -- has gone underground since gunmen abducted his brother and threatened to kill him unless he stopped supporting the cease-fire and speaking out against more extremist militia members.

"We want people to come back to the Sadr movement and believe in us again," he said. "We hope this new direction will allow us to rebuild our relationship with the people and make them believe we are good again."
I have no idea if this will happen but frankly despite it being rather dangerous (for us and those Iraqis who don't want to live in a Islamic theocracy) if this happen it would be a good thing. Al Sadr should still be arrested for his many crimes and made to pay for them so don't expect changes in my sig anytime soon.

Still if they want to found a fundamentalist religious party thing... *looks at the south* I don't see how we're in any position to stop them. Besides, Iraq has a right to have it's own Jerry Falwell to. (still not changing the sig).
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#2

Post by frigidmagi »

BBC
A spokesman for Iraqi Shia cleric Moqtada Sadr says his militia will no longer carry weapons, but he stopped short of declaring an end to violence.

In a BBC interview, Salah al-Obeidi said future decisions about the Mehdi Army's strategy would depend on the long-term status of US troops in Iraq.

"Resistance" would go on if a timetable for US withdrawal was not set, he said.

Iraq and the US are negotiating a status of forces agreement to decide the future role of US troops.

An announcement is expected to be read out at prayers in many Shia mosques in Baghdad on Friday.

The BBC's Crispin Thorold in Baghdad says the Mehdi Army was once arguably the most powerful Shia military and political movement in Iraq, but it has been seriously weakened after military operations against it.

Local ceasefires were declared in Basra and Baghdad earlier year year after intense fighting, but the militia still retains its weapons.

In June, the militia announced a reorganisation along the lines of Hezbollah in Lebanon - turning it into a large social movement with small secretive fighting units.

Separately, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Maliki has given militants in Diyala province, north of Baghdad, a week to lay down their arms.

He said those that did so would receive an amnesty.

So far, almost 500 suspected militants have been captured in an offensive there over the past eight days.
Well it's official then. Whether it's the actual reality as opposed to the official reality remains to be seen (still not changing sig).
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
Cpl Kendall
Disciple
Posts: 856
Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 2:16 pm
19
Location: Ontario, Canada

#3

Post by Cpl Kendall »

I thought the US was bribing this guy, so he would basically sit tight until they left and then go on a killing spree.
User avatar
frigidmagi
Dragon Death-Marine General
Posts: 14757
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:03 am
19
Location: Alone and unafraid

#4

Post by frigidmagi »

I'm pretty sure we're not giving money to a Cleric hiding in Iran. You may be confusing him with the Sunni Tribal Councils who are being bribed by the US and others(Canada's actually coughed up a bit of cash for that on the QT I've heard it claimed). Also it's hard to go on a killing spree if you've given up all your weapons. It could be he's got hidden caches and is just trying to buy time for further infiltration of the Army and Police. We will just have to see.
"it takes two sides to end a war but only one to start one. And those who do not have swords may still die upon them." Tolken
User avatar
Cpl Kendall
Disciple
Posts: 856
Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 2:16 pm
19
Location: Ontario, Canada

#5

Post by Cpl Kendall »

frigidmagi wrote:I'm pretty sure we're not giving money to a Cleric hiding in Iran. You may be confusing him with the Sunni Tribal Councils who are being bribed by the US and others(Canada's actually coughed up a bit of cash for that on the QT I've heard it claimed). Also it's hard to go on a killing spree if you've given up all your weapons. It could be he's got hidden caches and is just trying to buy time for further infiltration of the Army and Police. We will just have to see.
I probably am thinking of the tribal councils, hard to keep track of all the shit going on over there. I imagine Canada has thrown a little money into it, sounds like what the current governernment would do, likely out of the foriegn aid budget in the form of rice or something similar.
Post Reply